Interdisciplinary Design and Research Publication
Guidelines for Review of Articles

Reviewer name: _______________________________

Article title: _________________________________________________________

I. I recommend that this article

1. Be accepted for publication as is.
2. Be accepted with minor revisions as noted.
2. Be resubmitted with major revisions as noted and/or suggested.
3. Be rejected.

II. Explain your decision in (I). Please address the following

1. The quality of the article’s argument in relation to the theme of the issue.

2. The logical framework of the article.

3. The writing style and readability.

4. Other observations.

III. Suggestions for improvement. Please make suggestions related to (but not limited to)

1. Clarity of argument and logical framework.

2. Research methodology.

3. Use of examples.

4. Use of sources.

5. Use of illustrations.

6. Length (the IDRP requests that articles be approximately 4000 words, although would consider longer ones if the reviewer feels that the submission is exceptional).

7. Other suggestions.

Note: All reviews will be returned to the author blind, along with comments from the IDRP editorial committee if required.

---

ISSN: 1939-4659

Sponsored by the Interdisciplinary Design Institute of Washington State University.

The Design Institute is a center where faculty, practitioners, undergraduate as well as graduate students in Architecture, Interior Design, and Landscape Architecture come together to learn in an interdisciplinary setting, to share ideas, and to grow in ability to practice and research in the design fields.